Freshman QBs Are Defying Expectations – But Which Ones Are Truly Elite?
Evaluating first-year quarterbacks in college football is like trying to predict the weather—there are no guarantees, and every situation is unique. The speed of a young QB’s development hinges on factors like their supporting cast, offensive system, and even their mental maturity. Yet, despite the inevitable growing pains, these 10 freshmen (including redshirts) have already made waves in the first half of the season. And here’s the kicker: four of them are leading top-25 programs.
But here’s where it gets controversial: Should raw talent or immediate production weigh more in these rankings? Let’s dive in—and feel free to debate in the comments!
1. CJ Carr – Notre Dame Fighting Irish
Carr isn’t just the best freshman QB—he’s one of the most composed passers in the country, period. Despite Notre Dame’s losses to Miami and Texas A&M, Carr was the reason they stayed competitive. His 86.3 QBR (7th nationally) reflects near-flawless decision-making and pinpoint accuracy. With only 25 lost yards on negative plays and an 11:2 TD-to-INT ratio, he’s protecting the ball like a veteran.
At 6’3", 210 lbs, Carr has the arm strength to make every throw, but it’s his mental toughness that sets him apart. A former No. 2 pocket passer in the ESPN 300, he’s already flashing future top-five NFL draft pick potential.
Hot Take: If Notre Dame’s defense steps up, Carr could lead a playoff push—yes, as a redshirt freshman.
2. Julian Sayin – Ohio State Buckeyes
Critics will say Sayin benefits from Ohio State’s loaded roster, but don’t dismiss his near-perfect execution. Leading the nation with an 80.2% completion rate (including an 85% clinic against Minnesota), the redshirt freshman is a master of efficiency. With 13 TDs to just 3 INTs, he’s avoiding mistakes while delivering in clutch moments.
But here’s the catch: His stats are pristine, but will he falter when forced to carry the offense? For now, he’s the ideal game-manager for a title contender.
3. Bear Bachmeier – BYU Cougars
Bachmeier’s 5-0 start as a true freshman is impressive, but it hasn’t been smooth. Thrust into the spotlight after Jake Retzlaff’s departure, he’s leaned on BYU’s veteran roster and his own legs (he’s a dual-threat weapon). A 68% completion rate and just one turnover show reliability, but his deep-ball accuracy needs work.
Controversy Alert: Is he a system QB, or can he evolve into a true star? The next few weeks will tell.
4. Malik Washington – Maryland Terrapins
Washington’s raw tools are undeniable, but his downfield passing (just 51% beyond 5 yards) is a glaring weakness. Still, the former No. 3 dual-threat recruit has only turned the ball over once—a testament to his poise. With a favorable schedule (no Penn State or Ohio State), he could explode by season’s end.
Question for Debate: Should potential outweigh current flaws in rankings?
5. Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele – California Golden Bears
High-risk, high-reward defines Sagapolutele. His arm talent is elite, but erratic decisions (like a pick-six vs. San Diego State) are concerning. Cal’s shaky O-line isn’t helping, but his 17-of-38 stinker against Duke can’t be ignored.
Provocative Take: If he cleans up his play, he could skyrocket—but is that a big if?
6. Bryce Underwood – Michigan Wolverines
The former No. 1 overall recruit has shown flashes, but his 59% completion rate and just 3 TDs reveal growing pains. Facing Oklahoma’s defense exposed his inaccuracy, yet his athleticism and arm talent scream future star.
Fan Challenge: How much patience should Michigan fans have with their prized freshman?
7. Micah Alejado – Hawai’i Rainbow Warriors
The underdog story continues. Overlooked for his size, Alejado is completing 70% of his passes with zero turnovers. His 457-yard, 3-TD dismantling of Air Force proves he’s no fluke.
Underrated Angle: Could he be the steal of the 2025 recruiting class?
8. Brad Jackson – Texas State Bobcats
Jackson’s dual-threat dominance (7 TDs, 1 INT, plus 300 rushing yards) has Texas State eyeing a Sun Belt title. His breakout win over Arkansas State was a statement.
Debate Prompt: Should Group of Five standouts like Jackson get more hype?
9. Drake Lindsey – Minnesota Golden Gophers
Lindsey’s 65% completion rate is solid, but his struggles against Ohio State raise questions. With a tough schedule ahead, can the 6’5" pocket passer elevate his game?
10. Mason Heintschel – Pittsburgh Panthers
One start, one jaw-dropping performance: 323 yards, 4 TDs vs. Boston College. Small sample? Sure. But Pitt’s QB room just got interesting.
Final Thought: Which freshman QB are you betting on—or do you disagree with this list entirely? Sound off below!
